Opposing the Argument that Increased Longevity Will Slow Progress, and is Therefore Undesirable
Posted: August 4, 2013 at 2:57 am
Some opponents of increased human healthy longevity argue that if we begin to live for far longer than the present human life span then progress in technology will slow to a crawl. This is often presented as a variation on the stagnation argument: that long-lived people will cling to their ideas and their positions for decades or centuries, resisting all change. It is true that human nature comes with a strong conservative streak, and all change is opposed. But despite that fact change nonetheless happens on a timescale quite short in comparison to human life spans: leaders come and go, like fashions, and revolutions, and changes of opinion, and sweeping redefinitions in culture and society. Rare indeed are those that manage to last for a couple of decades, never mind longer. This pace of change in human affairs is essentially the same as that of the ancient world, despite our much greater adult life expectancy in comparison to the classical Greek period or Roman empire.
If we want to look at raw correlations on the other hand, it seems that the technologies needed to extend healthy life go hand in hand with an increased rate of technological progress. Longevity has made the human world become wealthier and run faster, opening doors of opportunity rather than closing them. The only way to increase the healthy human life span is through the creation of a broad pyramid of enabling technologies that in turn lead to faster progress in all fields, not just medicine. Computing is the present dominant enabler, for example, not just for biotechnology but also for almost all other fields of endeavor. If human nature to date has failed to hold back the tide of progress, I'd say it has little chance at doing so in the future: progress is only speeding up.
As is pointed out in the article excerpted below, people change throughout their lives. This also is the same as in the times of antiquity, despite much longer life spans. Human nature is human nature, and the caricature of inflexible, static old people is just that: a caricature. Minds change, and where the elderly are in fact forced into smaller and smaller circles it is largely through disability and frailty, not choice: the failing body and mind narrow the accessible vista, not the lack of will.
Combatting the "Longer Life Will Slow Progress" Criticism
We are all still children. As far as the Centenarian is concerned, the only people to have ever lived have been children - and we have all died before our coming of age. What if humans only lived to age 20? Consider how much less it would be possible to know, to experience, and to do. Most people would agree that a maximum lifespan of 20 years is extremely circumcising and limiting - a travesty. However, it is only because we ourselves have lived past such an age that we feel intuitively as though a maximum lifespan of 20 years would be a worse state of affairs than a maximum lifespan of 100. And it is only because we ourselves have not lived past the age of 100 that we fail to have similar feelings regarding death at the age of 100. This doesn't seem like such a tragedy to us - but it is a tragedy, and arguably one as extensive as death at age 20.
The current breadth and depth of the world and its past are far too gargantuan to be encompassed by a mere 100 years. If you really think that there are only so many things that can be done in a lifetime, you simply haven't lived long enough or broadly enough. There is more to the wide whorl of the world than the confines and extents of our own particular cultural narrative and native milieu.
Luckily, functional decline as a correlate of age is on the way out. We will live to 100 not in a period of decline upon hitting our mid-twenties, but in a continuing period of youthfulness. There are no longevity therapies on the table that offer to truly prolong life indefinitely without actually reversing aging. Thus, one of the impediments preventing us from seeing death at 100 as a tragedy, as dying before one's time, will be put to rest as well. When we see a 100 year old die in future, they will have the young face of someone who we feel today has died before their time. We won't be intuitively inclined to look back upon the gradual loss of function and physiological-robustness as leading to and foretelling this point, thereby making it seem inevitable or somehow natural. We will see a terribly sad 20 year old, wishing they had more time.
It seems to me a truism that we get smarter, more ethical and more deliberative as we age. To think otherwise is in many cases derivative of the notion that physiology and experience alike are on the decline once we "peak" in our mid-twenties, downhill into old age - which does undoubtedly happen, and which inarguably does cause functional decline. But longevity therapies are nothing more nor less than the maintenance of normative functionality; longevity therapies would thus not only negate the functional decline that comes with old age, [but also] the source of the problem arguably at the heart of the concern that longer life will slow progress.
Increasing longevity will not bring with it prolonged old-age, a frozen decay and decrepit delay, but will instead prolong our youthful lives and make us continually growing beings, getting smarter and more ethical all the time.
Lastly, this thought: so what if increased life spans did slow progress? Even in the hypothetical world in which that did look even remotely plausible, it is still the case that for so long as the pace of longevity is greater than the slowdown, everyone still comes out ahead. Being alive and in good health is the important thing: given that, the only thing that matters with regard to further technological progress is whether it is happening fast enough to keep you alive and in good health. Everything else in life is what you make of it.
- Grand Traverse Co. Health Department Seeks Volunteers for Hagerty Center Vaccination Clinics - 9&10 News - January 20th, 2021
- How to live longer: Should you skip breakfast to promote longevity? Doctor weighs in - Express - December 28th, 2020
- China Long Avoided Talking About Mental Health. Then Covid Hit. - The New York Times - December 22nd, 2020
- With fitness centers shut down due to COVID-19, home gyms are on the rise - SW News Media - December 10th, 2020
- Review: Equinox Takes Luxe Fitness Into The Wild at Their First Outdoor Gym in LA - InsideHook - September 30th, 2020
- Colorados fitness industry starting to reawaken, but some studios will never reopen - Loveland Reporter-Herald - June 16th, 2020
- In sickness and in health: North Spokane couple weds in front yard during pandemic - The Spokesman-Review - May 18th, 2020
- Furry Friends Provide Big Benefits - June 20th, 2018
- CT Nutrition Consultants - Registered Dietitian - July 12th, 2017
- Channel Update - Fitness & Football Videos Only! - Video - August 10th, 2014
- Measuring the Impact of Cytomegalovirus in Younger People - September 1st, 2013
- Decreased mTOR Expression Provides 20% Mean Life Span Extension in Mice - September 1st, 2013
- A Collagen Patch to Spur Heart Tissue Repair - September 1st, 2013
- Statin Use Correlates With Higher Telomerase Activity - September 1st, 2013
- Children of Long-Lived Parents Have Better Immune Systems - September 1st, 2013
- A Two-Part Report on Global Futures 2045 - August 25th, 2013
- The Next Few Years of Research Into Alzheimer's Disease - August 25th, 2013
- A Look Back at Some of the Roots of Modern Thought on Radical Life Extension - August 25th, 2013
- Damaging the Biology of Mice to Make them Age More Rapidly Often Tells Us Little of Use - August 25th, 2013
- Calorie Restriction as a Means to Augment Cancer Therapies - August 25th, 2013
- Life Without Ageing: Aubrey de Grey and Tom Kirkwood to Debate Longevity Science at the British Science Festival - August 18th, 2013
- A Short Overview of 3-D Printing in Tissue Engineering - August 18th, 2013
- Another Way to Improve Memory in Old Mice - August 18th, 2013
- SENS Research Foundation Releases 2013 Research Report - August 18th, 2013
- Targeting Redox Biology to Reverse Mitochondrial Dysfunction - August 18th, 2013
- The Cost of Living Longer, Even in Good Health - August 11th, 2013
- Signs of Progress: Insurers Talk of Radical Life Extension - August 11th, 2013
- The Current State of Knowledge of Genetics and Longevity - August 11th, 2013
- A Video Tour of Alcor and Interview With Max More - August 11th, 2013
- And Now For Something Reprehensible - August 11th, 2013
- Considering State Opposition to Life Extension Technologies - August 4th, 2013
- Steps Towards a Tissue Engineered Thymus - August 4th, 2013
- The Intersection of Kickstarter-Style Fundraising for Research and Distributed Development in Complex Problems - August 4th, 2013
- The Cost of Being Tall is a Shorter Life Expectancy - August 4th, 2013
- A Little Methionine Restriction Research - June 16th, 2013
- Calorie Restriction Versus Resveratrol Treatment - June 16th, 2013
- Reviewing the Literature on Calorie Restriction and Oxidative Stress - June 16th, 2013
- Arguing By Induction For an Absence of Boredom in an Ageless, Greatly Extended Healthy Life - June 16th, 2013
- Investigating Fingertip Regeneration in Mammals - June 16th, 2013
- The Incentives Associated With Becoming a Machine Entity - June 9th, 2013
- A Good Scientific Polemic on Aging - June 9th, 2013
- Quantifying Neurogenesis in Adult Humans - June 9th, 2013
- Considering the Details of Replacing the Brain - June 9th, 2013
- Overreacting in the Direction of Doing Nothing - June 9th, 2013
- Considering the Regenerative Signals Emitted by Transplanted Stem Cells - June 2nd, 2013
- A Bioprosthetic Heart - June 2nd, 2013
- Exercise Versus Peripheral Artery Disease - June 2nd, 2013
- Bracketed by Billionaires - June 2nd, 2013
- Stem Cell Transplants for Leukemia Showing Improved Outcomes - June 2nd, 2013
- Videos from the SENS Research Foundation Evidence Studios Event in December 2012 - May 26th, 2013
- Early Mortality Rates Predict Late Mortality Rates - May 26th, 2013
- Decellularization May Enable Use of More Donor Organs - May 26th, 2013
- Mitochondrially Targeted Antioxidant SS-31 Reverses Some Measures of Aging in Muscle - May 26th, 2013
- Arguing for the Role of Nuclear DNA Damage in Aging - May 26th, 2013
- Reviewing the Results of Calorie Restriction Primate Studies - May 19th, 2013
- A Possible Biomarker for Senescent Cells - May 19th, 2013
- Inhibiting ICMT as a Progeria Therapy - May 19th, 2013
- Are the Most Influential Futurists Those Who Put in the Work to Make Their Visions Real? - May 19th, 2013
- Excess Body Fat Hardens Arteries - May 19th, 2013
- Comments on Rapamycin and Metformin - May 12th, 2013
- The Present State of Artificial Retinas - May 12th, 2013
- The State of Electromechanical and Bioartifical Organs - May 12th, 2013
- Parabiosis Points to GDF-11 as a Means to Reverse Age-Related Cardiac Hypertrophy - May 12th, 2013
- Insights into Inflammaging - May 12th, 2013
- A Different Take on NF-?B and the Hypothalamus - May 5th, 2013
- T-Regulatory Cells More Numerous in the Aged Immune System - May 5th, 2013
- HMGA1 as a Potential Common Mechanism in Cancer - May 5th, 2013
- Recent Research Results from the Study of Naked Mole Rats - May 5th, 2013
- A Skeptical View of Mitochondrial DNA Damage and Aging - May 5th, 2013
- Recent Calorie Restriction Research - April 28th, 2013
- Joining the Dots in Genetic Parkinson's Disease - April 28th, 2013
- Considering the Electron Transport Chain in Aging - April 28th, 2013
- More Data on Granulocyte Transplant Cancer Therapies - April 28th, 2013
- Measures of Mitochondrial DNA Damage Lower in Long-Lived Mice - April 28th, 2013
- Aubrey de Grey on "The Undoing of Aging" - April 21st, 2013
- Mitochondrial Functional Mutations and Worm Longevity - April 21st, 2013
- Indy Mutations and Fly Longevity - April 21st, 2013
- Further Research on BubR1, Cellular Senescence, and Aging - April 21st, 2013
- Sterilized Dogs Live Longer - April 21st, 2013
- Robust Cancer Therapies Will Mean a Greater Use of Aggressive Stem Cell Therapies - April 14th, 2013